Site Loader

INTRODUCTION:

In recent years, the number of active users across social media platforms, including X (formerly Twitter), Facebook, and Instagram, has increased significantly, with over 38 million social media identities in Nigeria. Accompanying this rapid growth came a corresponding rise in incidents of false accusations, cyber defamation, and online intimidation. Therefore,rather than serving solely as platforms for social expression and civic engagement, these digital spaces have, in some instances, been weaponized by individuals seeking to malign unsuspecting users, tarnish reputations, and inflict harm. This has made it essential and imperative for social media users to be aware of and understand the basic guidelines and laws governing online engagement, content creation, and their legal implications.

What is Cyber defamation?

Black’s Law Dictionary defines defamation is the taking of one’s reputation. It is an offense that involves injuring a person’s character, fame, or reputation by false and malicious statements. Section 373 of the Criminal Code, states that defamatory matters are matters likely to injure the reputation of any person by exposing him to hatred, contempt, or ridicule, or likely to damage a person in his profession or trade by any injury to his reputation. The Cybercrimes (Prohibition, Prevention, etc.) Act, 2015 does not expressly define cyber defamation, However, Section 24 of the Act criminalizes certain harmful online communications, including the transmission of false messages intended to cause injury, intimidation, hatred, ill will, or needless anxiety to another person.

These laws aim to balance the right to freedom of expression with the protection of individuals and organizations from false and damaging statements.

FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION AND ITS LIMITS

The right to freedom of expression is guaranteed under Section 39 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended), which entitles every person to hold opinions and to receive and impart ideas and information without interference. In the digital age, this guarantee extends naturally to social media, where millions of Nigerians now engage in public exchange of opinions.

However, this right to expression is not absolute. Section 45(1) of the Constitution permits certain limitations on that right where they are reasonably justifiable; such instances include protecting public safety, public order, and the rights and freedoms of other persons. It is within this provision that cyber defamation laws finds its authority and justification. The freedom to express thoughts, post reports, and content online does not extend to the publication of false and damaging statements about others.

Cyber defamation occurs when a false statement, published through digital means, whether through a post, comment, tweet, or viral video, damages the reputation of an identifiable person. In Ologe v New Africa Holdings Ltd, the court held that to establish liability, a claimant must prove that the statement is defamatory, that it identifies them, and that it was communicated to at least one third party.

A statement is defamatory if it tends to lower the claimant in the estimation of right-thinking members of society, or expose them to hatred or ridicule. In the case of Sketch Publishing Co. Ltd v. Ajagbemokeferi Sketch Publishing Co. Ltd v. Ajagbemokeferi (1989) 1 NWLR (Pt. 100) 678, the Court of Appeal affirmed that this standard is objective. However, it is not what the defendant intended, but how a reasonable person would interpret the statement, that determines liability. A user who publishes a damaging falsehood online, whether in anger or in pursuit of likes and engagement, cannot escape liability by pleading innocent intent if a reasonable reader would understand the post to be damaging.

LEGAL CONSEQUENCES OF CYBER DEFAMATION

The laws pertaining to cyber-defamation do not exist in isolation. A person who publishes false and damaging content about another on social media does not merely commit a moral wrong; they expose themselves to both civil and criminal legal liability.

Civil Liability

The primary civil remedy for cyber defamation is an action in tort, and to succeed, a party must establish six co-terminus ingredients as laid down by the Supreme Court in Ologe & Ors v. New Africa Holdings Ltd (2013) LPELR-20181 (SC). They are;

  • That the words were published;
  • That they were defamatory in nature;
  • That they referred to the claimant;
  • That they were false;
  • That they were published maliciously,
  • That the claimant suffered damage as a result.

Once these ingredients have been successfully established, the law treats the wrong as proven, and the defamed person becomes entitled to a remedy. Social media users must realize that a post framed as an expression of opinion does not escape liability if a reasonable reader would take it to lower the subject’s reputation in the eyes of right-thinking members of society.

It is also important to note that online posts, tweets, WhatsApp broadcasts, and videos constitute libel (defamation in a permanent form) and are actionable. The claimant does not need to prove specific damage; once a defamatory statement is published online, the law presumes harm has been done and awards general damages as a matter of course. Where liability is established in a civil suit on cyber-defamation, available remedies include general damages, special damages for specific quantifiable losses, aggravated or punitive damages where the defendant’s conduct compounded the harm, and injunctive relief restraining further publication.

These damages are intended to compensate the defamed party for the damage and injury done to his/her reputation and, in certain cases, which must be proved, compensation for loss of business, earnings, and profits as a result of the defamatory statement. A retraction and apology, while a remedy, may only mitigate the weight of damages awarded.

An essential aspect of  defamation is the Republication Rule. This rule states that a person who repeats, shares, reposts, and forwards a defamatory statement made by a person is as liable for defamation as though he were the original publisher. Under Cyber-defamation laws, each fresh publication of a defamatory statement gives rise to a separate cause of action as seen in Ogbonnaya v. Mbalewe. Hence, every share, retweet, or repost of defamatory content is a fresh act of publication, and every person who republishes it is potentially liable.

Criminal Liability

Beyond civil courts, Nigerian law imposes criminal sanctions for cyber defamation and online intimidation. Section 24(1) of the Cybercrimes (Prohibition, Prevention, etc.) Act, 2015, criminalizes the knowing transmission of grossly offensive, false, or menacing messages intended to cause injury, hatred, intimidation, or needless anxiety to another person. A conviction attracts a fine of ₦7,000,000 (Seven Million Naira) or imprisonment for three years, or both. In the southern states, section 375 of the Criminal Code Act provides additional criminal liability for defamatory publications.

EXCEPTIONS AND DEFENCE TO DEFAMATORY ACTIONS

The law recognizes that not every damaging statement attracts liability. When a person successfully raises an exception or defence to a defamatory statement, it reduces his liability or shields him absolutely. These exceptions and defence includes;

  • FAIR COMMENT:

This a statement of opinion based on public interest, and this opinion must be honest, based on fact, and not motivated by malice. However, to rely on this defense, the party must prove that the statement was a comment based on true facts and was in the public interest.

  • CONSENT:

Where the person who is alleged to have been defamed consented to or authorized the publication of the statement, no liability arises. A person cannot complain about the publication of information they themselves agreed to have disclosed.

  • TRUTH:

The truth of a statement is an absolute defence. No one has the right to complain about a statement that is substantially true. In Oruwari v. Osler (2013) 5 NWLR (Pt. 1348) 535, the Court of Appeal held that “truth is a complete defence to defamation, for the law does not protect a man from the publication of that which is true about him.

  • QUALIFIED PRIVILEGED:

Certain communications made in the performance of a duty or in the protection of a legitimate interest are privileged. This defence will fail only where malice is proved. In Emeagwara v. Star Printing & Publishing Co. Ltd (2000) 14 NWLR (Pt. 688) 372, the court affirmed that a statement made in good faith, in discharge of a duty, is privileged.

CONCLUSION

While social media has expanded opportunities for expression and engagement, it has also heightened the need for all internet users to adopt good internet manners and culture. Freedom of expression is a fundamental right, but it does not extend to false and harmful publications. In the digital age, every post matters, and every publication carries potential legal consequences.

Ruben Onyeka Nwazufu

Associate

Post Author: Augustsons

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *